Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream

A cocoa rich pint with broken mini peanut butter cups folded through on the mix in. Every spoonful lands a cup chunk.

↓ Jump to recipe
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream
Ninja CreamiPrep
10 min
Freeze
24 hours
Makes
1 pint · 4 servings

Why you’ll love this

Chocolate and peanut butter, the greatest duo in the freezer, in every single spoonful; the base is rich and cocoa deep, and the broken cups stay chunky so each bite lands a little candy surprise. It is made for serious snackers and anyone who hoards the peanut butter cups at Halloween.

What you’ll need

A few simple ingredients for a big, delicious idea.

Cream cheese
Cream cheese
Cocoa powder
Cocoa powder
Granulated sugar
Granulated sugar
Vanilla extract
Vanilla extract
Heavy cream
Heavy cream
Whole milk
Whole milk
Mini peanut butter cups
Mini peanut butter cups

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream

Ninja CreamiPrep 10 min24 hours

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Make the base

    Put the cream cheese in a large microwave safe bowl and microwave for 10 seconds. Add the cocoa powder, sugar, and vanilla extract and whisk until the mixture looks like frosting, about 60 seconds.

  2. Whisk in the cream

    Slowly mix in the heavy cream and milk until fully combined and the sugar is dissolved.

  3. Freeze the pint

    Pour the base into an empty pint, place the storage lid on, and freeze for 24 hours.

  4. Set up the pint

    Take the pint out of the freezer and remove the storage lid, then set the pint up in the machine.

  5. Select ICE CREAM

    Select ICE CREAM and let the program spin the frozen base into ice cream.

  6. Add the peanut butter cups

    With a spoon, create a 1½ inch wide hole that reaches the bottom of the pint. Add the broken mini peanut butter cups to the hole and process again using the MIX-IN program.

  7. Serve

    When processing is complete, take the ice cream out of the pint and serve immediately.

Nutrition guide

The nutrition scoop

Per serving · 1 of 4 servings from one pint

  • Fat 61%
  • Carbs 34%
  • Protein 5%

Proper dessert energy: rich and satisfying, the way a scoop should be.

Total fat 23 g
Carbohydrates 28 g
Protein 5 g
of which sugars 26 g
Saturated fat 13 g 67% daily value
Cholesterol 70 mg 24% daily value
Sodium 85 mg 4% daily value
Dietary fiber 1 g 5% daily value
Calcium 110 mg 9% daily value
Vitamin C 0 mg 0% daily value

Where the calories live

The heavy cream brings the biggest share of the calories here, about 47 percent of the batch, with the granulated sugar next in line.

The bright spot

Most of the flavor rides on the heavy cream, and the numbers stay in treat territory rather than meal territory.

Want a lighter scoop

Swap half the heavy cream for whole milk. The spin stays creamy and every serving lands noticeably lighter.

Estimated from the ingredients exactly as written, using standard reference values for each ingredient. Your brands and swaps will shift the numbers a little. Daily values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet.

Make it your own

  • Start with the base recipe, then swap one ingredient at a time.
  • Try a different topping after processing.
  • Keep notes so you can revisit your favorite combination.

Texture tips

  • A level, fully solid freeze gives the smoothest spin.
  • Freeze CREAMi bases level and completely solid.
  • For SLUSHi, check compatible liquids and minimum sugar requirements.

Frequently asked questions

Can I make it dairy free?

Yes. Use vegan cream cheese for the cream cheese, unsweetened coconut cream for the heavy cream, unsweetened oat milk for the whole milk, and vegan chocolate peanut butter cups for the mix in.

Why break the cups before the mix in?

Broken pieces disperse through the whole pint instead of landing in a few big pockets, and the machine folds them in without a fight.

What if the pint looks crumbly?

Run the respin program once before adding the mix in. A very cold freezer often needs that extra pass.

Can I prep several pints at once?

Yes. Prepping several pints in one session means a spin on demand whenever a craving strikes; just keep the cups aside until each pint is spun.